“Sur un fil : Les critiques publiques sur le premier film de Reda Kateb”

Released on October 30, *Sur un fil* has garnered mixed reviews, achieving a 3.2 out of 5 from critics and an impressive 4.1 from audiences. This marks the directorial debut of Reda Kateb, with Aloïse Sauvage also making her first leading role. The film, inspired by the true story of the *Rire Médecin* association and based on Caroline Simonds’ book, explores the impact of hospital clowns. While many praised its sincerity and emotional depth, some critics noted a predictable storyline. The film is currently showing in theaters.

Released on Wednesday, October 30, has “Sur un fil” won over its initial audiences? While it garnered an average rating of 3.2 out of 5 from critics (based on 29 reviews), it boasts a 4.1 out of 5 from the public, thanks to the 90 ratings received so far (including 45 reviews). That’s a fantastic score!

“Sur un fil” marks a directorial debut for Reda Kateb. The actor, known for his roles in “Un Prophète” and “Hippocrate,” has taken the plunge into filmmaking with this being his first feature film.

This film also represents a first for Aloïse Sauvage, who secures her lead role. The singer, who has a background in circus arts, delivers a performance perfectly tailored to her, showcasing her extensive range in this tender and poignant film, inspired by the real-life story of the charity “Le Rire Médecin.” The film draws from Caroline Simonds’ book, who founded the association in France, chronicling her experiences in a journal titled Le Rire Médecin: Journal du docteur Girafe, published by Albin Michel.

An Emotional and Heartfelt Film

Viewers have been moved by the film’s sincerity and emotional depth.

capirex (4/5): ‘Reda Kateb’s directorial debut is a genuine success that takes the audience on a rollercoaster of emotions! The film also explores the role of art in dealing with both physical and psychological pain. Aloïse Sauvage, with her circus training, is perfect in her role!

Bernard Coric (4/5): ‘This first feature by Reda Kateb is a commendable achievement. He thoughtfully explores the world of hospital clowns with seriousness and emotion. Beyond the well-researched nature of the film, the character casting is spot-on and effective. The screenplay is well-balanced.

Check out our podcast interview with Reda Kateb and Aloïse Sauvage:

Viewers have highlighted the film’s humanity, blending laughs with poignant moments, all delivered by a stellar cast.

Caro cinéma (4.5/5): ‘A deeply human film that hits right in the heart… Sincerity and truth still resonate…

Is the Plot Too Predictable?

While most viewers appreciate the film, some critics lament its somewhat predictable and formulaic plot.

traversay1 (2.5/5): ‘There’s little that surprises in a narrative that lacks ambition in its direction. An audience familiar with the subject will feel a reasonable emotional response but won’t find many unexpected elements in a treatment that, while not entirely bland, could use a few more rough edges.

Yann C (3/5): ‘There’s a vibrant, joyful, and human intent that occasionally captivates, but unfortunately, the storyline is a bit too formulaic and predictable for full enjoyment.

For context, the film follows Jo, a young street circus performer, as she discovers the work of professional clowns at “Nez pour rire.” Quickly—perhaps too quickly—joining the association, she finds herself in hospitals, interacting with children, patients, caregivers, and families, all of whom the clowns endeavor to bring joy and comfort to.

“Sur un fil” is currently playing in theaters.

Latest