Concerns about France’s safety have surged following a viral post claiming it has the lowest safety rating for walking alone at night among 41 countries. The source of this claim, Numbeo, relies on user-submitted data, raising questions about its reliability. In contrast, Eurostat’s official statistics show France ranks tenth in homicide rates, lower than several European countries. Surveys indicate that a majority of French citizens feel safe, suggesting that France is not among the most dangerous nations in Europe.
Is France Really One of Europe’s Most Dangerous Countries?
Recent discussions on social media, particularly a viral post on X dated February 11, have sparked concerns about France’s safety. The post, which has garnered nearly a million views, claims that the country has the lowest safety rating for walking alone at night among 41 countries. But how credible are these claims? Let’s delve into the details.
Understanding the Source of the Claims
The origin of the information comes from Numbeo, a website known for its global rankings on various topics such as crime rates, public health, and cost of living. However, it’s important to note that Numbeo’s methodology relies heavily on user-submitted data rather than official statistics. The site allows anyone to fill out a questionnaire about their experiences in different cities worldwide, which can lead to questionable reliability. In our own test, we submitted feedback on Belgium without any verification of residency. The platform does have some safeguards against spam, but this does not ensure the accuracy of the data collected.
As a result, the findings can be misleading. The lack of stringent checks on who contributes data means that the sample size may not accurately represent the population. For instance, when looking at the crime rate, only 5,335 responses have been logged since the survey’s inception, which is insufficient for drawing valid conclusions, as confirmed by Antoine Jardin, a political science researcher at CNRS.
Comparing Data: What Do Official Statistics Reveal?
When looking for a more reliable perspective on crime in France, Eurostat, the European Union’s statistical office, offers valuable insights. This organization calculates crime rates based on the number of homicides per 100,000 inhabitants, providing a clearer picture of safety across Europe. According to their data, France is not in last place; rather, it ranks tenth, with a homicide rate of 1.21 per 100,000 inhabitants in 2022. This rate is below the European average and is lower than those of countries like Estonia, Albania, and Turkey, which has a rate of 2.46.
However, it’s crucial to recognize that homicide rates alone do not capture the complete picture of public safety. The perception of insecurity also plays a significant role. To gauge this, victimization surveys are essential as they ask a representative sample of the population about their experiences with crime, including those incidents that may not be reported to the police. Unfortunately, such surveys are not conducted annually by Eurostat.
In 2017, the European Commission undertook a special barometer to assess EU citizens’ perceptions of security. The findings showed that 67% of French respondents felt their country was safe, which is only slightly below the EU average. This robust methodology indicates that France is far from being one of the most dangerous countries in Europe, with perceptions of safety higher than those in the United Kingdom and Croatia.
Do you have questions or wish to share information regarding this topic? Reach out to us at [email protected] or connect with us on X at @verif_TF1LCI!