This piece explores the pricing dynamics of password managers, highlighting the challenges of comparing subscription models that often include long-term discounts. It emphasizes the importance of security and features in high-quality password managers, comparing top choices like Keeper, Bitwarden, and Enpass. Keeper excels in security and functionality, Bitwarden offers affordability and user-friendly features, while Enpass presents a one-time purchase option for those avoiding subscriptions. A comparison table showcases the strengths and weaknesses of 11 tested managers.
Understanding the Pricing of Password Managers
When it comes to password managers, comparing prices can be quite challenging. Many applications are available only through subscription models, often providing discounts for long-term commitments. To help you navigate this, we have calculated the projected costs of various password managers over a three-year period.
What Makes a Quality Password Manager?
A top-notch password manager delivers a comprehensive package that includes security, usability, and a variety of features. While pricier options typically boast enhanced functionalities—like advanced synchronization methods and greater flexibility for power users—more affordable choices can still hold their own in these areas. However, budget-friendly password managers may fall short on security, even if they still receive decent ratings.
Here, ‘security’ refers to how well the software assists in creating robust passwords, supports passkeys or security keys, and alerts users about potential breaches in known online services. While these features may not be essential for everyday users who know how to create secure passwords, they certainly contribute to a more secure experience.
Below, we highlight our top-performing password manager and compare it with the best value option. We also feature an excellent product that requires only a one-time purchase, eliminating ongoing subscription fees.
Password Managers at a Glance
Here we present a selection of 11 tested password managers, showcasing their strengths and weaknesses:
| Test Winner | Price Tip | Best without Subscription |
|---|---|---|
| Keeper | Bitwarden | Enpass |
| Very Good (1.0) | Good (2.3) | Good (2.1) |
| €125 (Keeper Security) | €28 (Bitwarden Inc.) | €93 (Enpass) |
In-Depth Analysis of Top Choices
Test Winner: Keeper
Keeper sets a high standard with its robust security framework, user-friendly interface, and extensive features. It not only evaluates the strength of your passwords but also allows for secure sharing and emergency recovery options. An additional service even alerts users if their credentials are found on the dark web. While Keeper works seamlessly across various platforms like Windows, Android, and iOS, those seeking alternative syncing solutions may find it lacking. Overall, Keeper is the leading all-in-one choice, albeit at a premium subscription cost.
Price Tip: Bitwarden
Bitwarden Premium offers an impressive security package that checks for weak passwords and prohibits easily guessable master passwords. Its straightforward operation across major platforms and the ability to set up a personal server for syncing data are significant advantages. However, the password sharing feature is limited to the more expensive family subscription. Despite this limitation, Bitwarden remains one of the most affordable options available, with a free version available for users wanting to try before they buy.
Best without Subscription: Enpass
For those wishing to avoid subscription fees, Enpass Individual provides a one-time purchase option with lifetime updates. It offers a commendable range of features and allows syncing with personal servers or cloud services, ensuring that users maintain control over their data. However, users must be technically savvy to manage the manual synchronization between devices, and it lacks support for physical security keys.