This article reviews various toothpaste tests conducted by consumer organizations, emphasizing the importance of fluoride in effective dental care. It highlights results from Stiftung Warentest, ÖKO-TEST, and others, revealing that many budget-friendly options scored well. Specific tests from 2024, 2023, and earlier years showcase winners and failures based on criteria like plaque removal and safety concerns over additives like titanium dioxide. Overall, it advocates for informed consumer choices in toothpaste selection for optimal dental health.
To effectively eliminate bacterial plaque from your teeth, dental professionals advise brushing twice daily for a minimum of two to three minutes. However, the success of your dental care routine hinges not only on the brushing technique and duration but also on the choice of toothpaste.
To help you make informed decisions, we have curated and summarized findings from various toothpaste reviews conducted by experts at Stiftung Warentest, ÖKO-TEST, AllesBeste, and Konsument.at. The primary focus across these evaluations has been on the ingredient fluoride, although there were notable differences among the tested products.
All reviewers emphasize the importance of using fluoride toothpaste. Additionally, abrasion levels—how well the toothpaste removes stains from coffee and tea—were considered by some testing organizations. Importantly, the tests demonstrated that a lower price does not necessarily correlate with subpar quality.
Stiftung Warentest Toothpaste Evaluation
2024 Test
In the latest issue (11/2024), Stiftung Warentest examined 18 new universal toothpastes, and all passed. However, two products were flagged for containing titanium dioxide, which has been banned as a food additive since August 2022 due to safety concerns. The top-rated toothpaste for 2024 is Blend-a-med Complete Expert 24H Protection, earning an impressive score of 1.3 (‘very good’).
2023 Test
Last year’s review (06/2023) assessed 45 universal toothpastes with price points ranging from 62 cents to 11 euros. The standout performer was the budget-friendly Prokudent Med from Rossmann, recognized for its exceptional cavity prevention and stain removal, scoring 1.4 (‘very good’).
While some products received high marks, others, like Bioniq Repair Med, were rated as ‘poor’ due to their ineffective formulations.
2022 Test
The findings from the 07/2022 test revealed five ‘very good’ toothpastes, including options for budget-conscious consumers. However, several established brands received low scores for lacking fluoride, compromising dental protection.
2020 Test
In 10/2020, Stiftung Warentest evaluated 115 toothpastes, showcasing both affordable store brands and reputable manufacturers, with low-cost options like Today dent Gentle White and brands such as Signal and Logodent achieving favorable reviews.
ÖKO-TEST Toothpaste Analysis
2023 Review
The 04/2023 issue of ÖKO-TEST analyzed 48 universal toothpastes, including 17 from certified natural cosmetics. It highlighted that the price does not always reflect quality, with nine budget-friendly options scoring ‘very good.’
A concerning 19 toothpastes were rated poorly, with 17 receiving ‘unsatisfactory’ evaluations.
2021 Review
In 10/2021, ÖKO-TEST found that nearly 25% of tested products did not meet quality standards, citing one or more harmful ingredients. Despite some mainstream brands performing poorly, a few stood out as winners.
Additional Toothpaste Tests: FAZ Kaufkompass & Konsument
FAZ Kaufkompass:
The FAZ Kaufkompass assessed 42 toothpastes, with Colgate Complete 8 Natural Herbs taking the top spot. However, many natural cosmetics failed, criticized for their inadequate surfactants and dull flavors.
Konsument:
The Austrian magazine Konsument concluded that cost-effective toothpastes can also provide excellent protection. Eleven out of fourteen products were rated highly, corroborating the findings from other outlets that natural cosmetic options often lack fluoride, leading to poor results.
The Best Electric Toothbrushes
Choosing the right toothbrush is equally essential for optimal dental care. Here, we highlight the four best electric toothbrushes, with more details available in our in-depth buying guide.
Top Electric Toothbrushes Tested by Stiftung Warentest
Test Winners:
Numerous models have been evaluated, with the latest winners from December 2023 and previous years showcasing a variety of styles and price points.
In summary, consistently choosing high-quality toothpaste along with an effective toothbrush is crucial for maintaining dental health and a bright smile.