Published
Update
Video length:
1 minute
TRUE OR FALSE. Is the testimony of a Gaza nurse who denounces Hamas crimes authentic?
In a testimony shared on Twitter, a nurse claims to be at Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza and certifies that “Hamas men” stole “morphine” intended for the sick. Is this testimony true? Response elements. – (franceinfo)
In a testimony shared on Twitter, a nurse claims to be at Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza and certifies that “Hamas men” stole “morphine” intended for the sick. Is this testimony true? Response elements.
A testimony assures that the Hamas controls the hospital Al Shifa from Gaza. In a video, a woman presented as a nurse denounces the crimes of Hamas. “I have to treat a five-year-old boy’s fracture without morphine because the men of the Hamas took it for themselves“, indicates this woman. Her testimony isis it authentic? The video, filmed in a very tight shot, cannot be geolocated. We only see this woman and a logo representing the Palestinian Ministry of Health. This element is supposed to prove that the scene takes place in a hospital in Gaza.
The sound of the bombs in question
However, certain elements call for caution regarding this testimony. First, it was first shared by pro-Israeli users. The first accounts to post it then deleted it. This is particularly the case for an “Israel in Arabic” account, managed by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Lior Haiatthe spokesperson for the ministry, justifies: “[La vidéo] was removed, because we could not verify its authenticity.“
Second, the exposure noises, which are heard at the back of the video, do not seem natural. Sound analysis experts noted that they happened precisely every 30 seconds. Their intensity and frequency are almost identical, which suggests that these explosions were added to the montage.