Former Republican President Donald Trump won another legal victory on Monday with the dismissal of all federal charges against him for withholding classified documents after he left the White House.
• Read also: Confidential documents: Trump lawyers seek stay of case
The Republican presidential candidate in November, who is to be officially sworn in at the party’s convention beginning Monday, was being sued along with two of his personal assistants over his handling of classified documents at his private Mar-a-Lago residence in Florida (southeast).
Donald Trump hailed it on his Truth Social network as “a first step”, calling for the cancellation of the three other criminal proceedings against him.
Judge Aileen Cannon granted a request by his lawyers to quash the proceedings, ruling that the appointment of special prosecutor Jack Smith, who is investigating the case, was unlawful.
Without ruling on the merits of the case, she claims that the appointment and funding of the special prosecutor violate the sections of the Constitution relating to appointments and expenses.
“The Court is convinced that Special Counsel Smith’s prosecution of this case violates two pillars of our constitutional order: the role of Congress in appointing officials under the Constitution and the role of Congress in authorizing legal spending,” the judge wrote.
Accordingly, all hearings scheduled in this case are cancelled.
The prosecution can, however, appeal this decision.
Partial criminal immunity
Donald Trump was accused of compromising national security by keeping the documents, including military plans and information on nuclear weapons, at home after his presidency ended, instead of handing them over to the National Archives as required by law.
Another law, on espionage, prohibits keeping state secrets in unauthorized and unsecured locations. He is also accused of trying to destroy evidence in the case. The most serious charges carried a maximum of 10 years in prison.
- Did the secret services act properly? Listen to Michel Juneau-Katsuya’s analysis:
Judge Cannon had already postponed indefinitely this trial, which was to begin on May 20.
Targeted by four criminal proceedings, Donald Trump is doing everything he can to be tried as late as possible, in any case after the election against Democratic President Joe Biden.
Found guilty on May 30 by the New York courts of “aggravated false accounting to conceal a plot to pervert the 2016 election,” he is due to be sentenced in September.
But he won an unexpected victory with the Supreme Court’s decision on July 1 granting the president of the United States broad criminal immunity.
In this unprecedented decision, the Court, hearing an appeal against the federal procedure, also brought by Jack Smith, for an attempt to illegally reverse the results of the 2020 election, considered that from a criminal perspective, “the president is entitled to at least a presumption of immunity for his official acts.”
She therefore referred the case back to the trial court to determine which acts are potentially immune from criminal prosecution, with the prosecution having to demonstrate that they are not when they were carried out in the exercise of its functions.
If re-elected, Donald Trump could, once inaugurated in January 2025, order a halt to federal prosecutions against him.