This article compares premium and budget sparkling water makers, emphasizing that while all models effectively carbonate water, differences in user comfort and features are significant. Budget options start at around 40 euros, while high-end models can reach 300 euros, often offering better craftsmanship and additional accessories. The top performer, Mysoda Ruby, excels in user experience and build quality, while the best value choice, Sodapop Cooper, is affordable and efficient despite some limitations.
Premium vs. Budget: Which Sparkling Water Maker Reigns Supreme?
In recent times, we have thoroughly explored a variety of sparkling water makers from numerous brands, analyzing their performance across different price points. One key takeaway is that all these devices effectively carbonate plain water with CO2, and they do so quite well. However, the disparity in pricing is apparent when it comes to user comfort and additional features, rather than CO2 efficiency.
You can find budget-friendly sparkling water makers starting at around 40 euros, while high-end models can soar up to 300 euros. The pricier options typically showcase superior craftsmanship, a multitude of accessories, and enhanced usability due to comfort features. Some brands have even introduced electric sparkling water makers. That said, it’s essential to weigh whether the extra perks of a wide range of accessories or an electric carbonation feature justify the steep price.
Interestingly, our tests revealed that budget models don’t fall short in carbonation efficiency; in some cases, they even outperform their more expensive counterparts.
Below, we will highlight the current top test performer and the best value for money option. You can find a comprehensive guide and all relevant information in our sparkling water maker evaluation.
Sparkling Water Maker Evaluation (Insights from 13 tested models)
Top Performer
Best Value
Plastic/Stainless Steel
Plastic
2
1
No
Yes
2 sec/l
3 sec/l
0.90 liters
0.94 liters
No
No
No
Yes
Excellent
Satisfactory
Excellent
Good
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
8.8 g/l
7.2 g/l
Acceptable (2.9)
Very economical (1.0)
130 €
(Amazon Marketplace: SodaTASTE GmbH)
44 €
(Media Markt)
Top Performer: Mysoda Ruby
Mysoda Ruby
Popular Shop
(Amazon Marketplace: SodaTASTE GmbH)
Cheaper Shop
(Amazon Marketplace: SodaTASTE GmbH)
Advantages
Includes 2 bottles
Exceptional user experience
Superior build quality
Very easy to maintain
Disadvantages
No drip tray included
Not dishwasher safe
Evaluation Summary
The Mysoda Ruby sparkling water maker delivers outstanding performance in our assessment. It offers continuous carbonation, is operable with one hand, and is constructed from high-quality materials. This is primarily due to its almost entirely stainless steel design. Weighing just under 2,000 grams with a generous base, it remains stable during use. Furthermore, the package includes two durable PET bottles with capacities of 0.9 and 0.45 liters, perfect for on-the-go hydration. Cleaning is a breeze: simply wipe the nozzle and device with a damp cloth. The bottles can be rinsed with hot water after each use, though they are not dishwasher safe. In addition to the absence of dishwasher compatibility, we also noted the lack of a drip tray to catch any spills.
For the full evaluation: Mysoda Ruby
Best Value: Sodapop Cooper
Sodapop Cooper
Popular Shop
(Media Markt)
Cheaper Shop
(Saturn)
Advantages
Budget-friendly
Includes a drip tray
Impressive carbonation efficiency
Simple to clean
Quick to assemble
Disadvantages
No gas cylinder included
Pressure relief valve is slightly open during use
Less stable
Not dishwasher safe
Evaluation Summary
The Sodapop Cooper impresses with its attractive price point. For this cost, you receive a reliable sparkling water maker featuring a drip tray and a 0.94-liter plastic bottle, though it’s not suitable for the dishwasher. The device is easy to clean and assembles quickly. However, unlike other models, it does not come with a gas cylinder. Additionally, we observed that the stability is lacking. Nevertheless, its carbonation efficiency of 7.2 grams per liter is commendable. Interestingly, during the carbonation process, we noted the pressure relief valve seems to be slightly open, producing a whistling sound; typically, this would lead to a loss of CO2. Yet, the measured CO2 efficiency tells a different story.
For the full evaluation: Sodapop Cooper
Comparison of Values
Select Option
: Indicates the number of included bottles.
Values in percent (%)
Our testing facility has analyzed these products under controlled laboratory conditions, verifying the results in collaboration with the specialist editorial team. Our evaluations are conducted with independence and transparency.