The journey toward sustainable and equitable food production began in the 1970s when Ursula Brunner questioned why imported bananas were cheaper than local apples. This sparked the Fair Trade movement in Switzerland, initially focusing on premium Chiquita bananas to support developing farmers. While efforts have been made towards sustainability, challenges remain, including misconceptions about organic labels and the complexities of banana production. Understanding the intricacies of agricultural practices is crucial for consumers seeking genuinely sustainable products.
The journey towards sustainable and fair food production began with a simple question posed by Ursula Brunner, a pastor’s wife and cantonal councilor from Thurgau, back in the 1970s: Why are bananas, an exotic fruit, cheaper than local apples? This inquiry unveiled the underlying injustices in the food system and led to the formation of a group known as the Banana Women, marking the inception of the Fair Trade movement in Switzerland.
Initially, the group focused on selling Chiquita bananas at a premium, channeling the extra funds into projects aimed at supporting banana farmers in developing nations. The iconic sticker featuring a black hand on these higher-priced bananas emerged as an early symbol of the Fair Trade initiative.
Ursula Brunner’s instincts were correct; the tropical fruit industry was indeed rife with issues. The tale of United Fruit, which eventually rebranded to Chiquita, reads like a gripping economic thriller, involving the company’s complicity in the overthrow of South American governments and its neglect of workers’ rights on plantations.
Despite efforts by Chiquita in the 1990s to improve sustainability and partner with retailers like Migros, the brand continues to struggle with its past reputation. “Chiquita made significant strides towards producing sustainable bananas,” says Philipp Aerni, a professor at the University of Applied Sciences in Freiburg and director of the Center for Corporate Responsibility and Sustainability (CCRS). “However, it hasn’t translated into a positive perception in retail.”
For consumers wishing to purchase sustainably and ethically produced bananas and other foods, organic and Fair Trade labels often take center stage. Yet, Aerni warns that such labels do not always guarantee that the products are genuinely sustainable.
Understanding Sustainability in Banana Production
To illustrate this point, consider the banana again. This tropical plant is vulnerable to various pests, particularly fungi that thrive in warm, humid climates. “To minimize pest issues in organic banana farming, growers often plant in drier areas,” explains Aerni. “However, this leads to increased water usage, which is not a sustainable practice given the water scarcity in those regions.”
In wetter areas, banana producers rely on fungicides to combat fungal threats, with the “Tropical Race 4” fungus being especially harmful. Australian researchers have developed a genetically modified banana resistant to this fungus, but it is not yet commercially available. The stigma surrounding genetically modified organisms may hinder its acceptance among consumers seeking sustainable options, despite the potential reduction in fungicide use.
“Sustainable products are frequently marketed as natural,” Aerni observes, noting a strong aversion to technology that complicates discussions about sustainability.
The Future of Sustainable Agriculture
Agriculture, far from being a romanticized endeavor in nature, is about transforming nature into cultivated landscapes, primarily through breeding. Take the banana, for example; nearly all bananas found in supermarkets come from the Cavendish variety, which is propagated through cloning in tissue culture labs. While this process may not be entirely natural, it can still be sustainable.
According to Aerni, “Sustainability implies future viability,” encompassing responsible resource use and the economic sustainability of producers. Farmers possess invaluable knowledge about their land and typically have a vested interest in applying resource-conserving methods. They frequently devise their own effective solutions.
When shopping for products from abroad, Aerni advises consumers to consider how the labels were developed. “Were the producers involved in the process? If yes, that’s a positive indicator. If the regulations were imposed externally, approach with caution.”
For local products, it’s important to understand the priorities of local farmers. Aerni explains, “In the past, an organic label was synonymous with sustainability. Today, it’s more nuanced. Sometimes conventional farms implement sustainable practices that are more tailored to their specific operations without the constraints of general certifications.”
Do you have questions regarding nutrition and health? Reach out to us at [email protected].