After the Quebec Bar and women’s groups, 400 doctors are warning the Legault government about the perils of a new law on the right to abortion.
“Quebec women do not need a law, but real access to reproductive health care,” wrote 402 doctors in a letter sent Monday to the Minister of Health, Christian Dubé. Communication, that The duty consulted, was also sent to the Prime Minister, François Legault, and to the Minister responsible for the Status of Women, Martine Biron.
The latter announced, in April, its intention to legislate to “sacralize” the right to abortion in Quebec. Mme Biron subsequently organized meetings with lawyers, women’s groups and health organizations.
In a series of public outings, representatives of these three groups tried to discourage the minister from moving forward with her proposal. By legislating, Mme Biron risks in fact opening the door to a limitation of the right to abortion, argued the Bar in particular. “As long as the law is on the table, we will continue to [faire] send the message that it’s a bad idea”, also told the Duty the DD Geneviève Bois.
The family doctor is one of the signatories of the letter sent to Minister Dubé. “Rather than a law, criticized by stakeholders in the field, whose potential to harm the right to abortion is significant, we are calling for the implementation of measures promoting access to abortion and reproductive health services in general,” write the doctors in the missive.
Free contraceptives
Based on a recent report from the Quebec Federation for Birth Planning (FQPN), doctors are calling on the Quebec government to “make prescription contraceptives free for all.”
“The right to have the abortion we want also means having the right not to get pregnant if we don’t want to,” argued the DD Bois in interview. In their letter, the doctors cite researchers who observed “that reducing the cost of contraceptives could increase their use and reduce unplanned pregnancies, particularly among less fortunate people.”
The right to have the abortion you want also means having the right not to get pregnant if you don’t want to.
This type of measure can also lead to long-term savings, underlined the Dr Elio Dario Garcia, president of the Association of Obstetricians and Gynecologists of Quebec. His organization supports the demands made in the doctors’ letter. “In medicine, the best thing to do is always prevention. When that doesn’t work, we move on to treatment. Here, prevention is access to contraception,” he told the Duty.
Mme Biron had a meeting with the vice-president of his association, he added. “The minister’s intention is good,” underlined the Dr Garcia. “But the worry we have is that […] it could give a chance in the other direction: that there are people who want to start to regulate more and limit access,” he continued.
Asked on Monday, Minister Biron’s office did not want to say whether the elected official was still moving forward with her legislative offensive. “Just like the doctors, we have read the FQPN report. We are in line with their recommendations,” wrote his press secretary, Catherine Boucher. The minister continues her analysis and her meetings. “Our intention is clear: to protect the right of women to choose abortion,” she stressed.
Better access
In addition to free contraceptives, the signatory doctors ask the government to “implement minimum standards to guarantee access to abortion services.” Clearly, they want Quebec to make a “real commitment” to “ensure access to abortion services throughout the province, within optimal time frames.”
Regions like Outaouais, Capitale-Nationale or Chaudière-Appalaches still only have one point of service for abortions, recalls the DD Drink. And “even if there are many points of service in theory, there were exactly zero that offered service in the evenings and weekends until a few months ago,” recalled the doctor. Service with extended hours has just started at a Montreal service center.
Waiting times, limited time slots: women who need an abortion sometimes have to travel long distances to get the services they need. “In Montreal, I serve women from Quebec and, in Gatineau, I serve women from Abitibi,” said the DD Drink.
With Florence Morin-Martel