In the room, the astonishment is great. Before showing up at the TLM-Un Tiers Lieu solidarity cooperative in Montreal, in the Plateau Mont-Royal, last Tuesday evening, the ten participants – the vast majority of them women – calculated their carbon footprint using a model developed by the French social economy company 2tonnes, behind this workshop now offered in thirty countries.
The annual average greenhouse gas emissions of the participants present is around 14 tonnes eq. CO2, which is slightly below the Canadian average (15 to 20 tonnes depending on the calculation methods). The smallest footprint is around 10 tonnes; the highest is twice as high.
Flexitarians, without a car, organic enthusiasts, many of them believe they are already doing a lot to reduce their footprint and find their results a bit discouraging.
Colossal Challenge
In fact, the objective of the workshop is as simple as the challenge is colossal. Using an interactive game, which takes place over eight rounds, spread over a fictional time sequence from 2023 to 2050, participants must lower their carbon footprint to 2 tonnes by choosing from a selection of action cards (by English for the moment, the main weak point of the workshop).
We alternate between the individual and the collective and between the themes: food, energy, transport, consumption, etc. There are also cards based on influence and mobilization, whose role should not be underestimated.
The model, built using data from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and the World Bank, takes into account the carbon footprint of public services such as hospitals, schools and roads. In Canada, this is estimated at 5 tonnes eq. CO2 per capita per year. So we start the exercise with a big deficit.
I may make individual gestures, this 5 tons is incompressible. It surprised me.
Geneviève Fournier-Goulet, CEGEP literature professor
The strength of a group
To act on this data, it will be necessary to adopt collective measures. Gathered around a table, the participants lend themselves to simulations, notably being parachuted into a COP27 assembly where each country must defend its interests.
The game is played blind. The workshop leader, Théo Chevalier, only reveals at the end of each round the gestures that have the most impact and the effects that our decisions have on our personal curves.
For now, these orders of magnitude are based on French data – the situation could be different for Quebec, in particular because of the energy mix. The model is not perfect, agrees the facilitator, but it is constantly being improved.
Some of the individual actions that have the most impact include adopting a flexitarian diet or even excluding red meat, using public transit, residential energy savings, and reducing air travel. .
Flying less is a heartbreaking decision for many participants who have family overseas. However, a round trip Montreal-Paris flight in economy class results in the emission of 1.9 tonnes eq. CO2. During the first round, few are ready to reduce their movements. But, as the window of time to act shrinks, the pressure mounts. In the year 2050, many reluctantly select the “Stop Stealing” card.
At the collective level, the group adopts measures to preserve natural areas, implement more sustainable agricultural practices, tax thermal cars, decarbonize energy production and, in 2050, impose a carbon emissions quota on citizens.
Despite all these radical actions, we will not be able to reach the 2 tonne target. The average of all the participants is 4.33 tonnes eq. CO2. However, thanks to the impact of collective measures, the world average has been lowered to 2.47 tonnes eq. CO2.
“With the choices you have made, you have succeeded in mobilizing 100% of the population,” congratulates Théo Chevalier. If there are more people who are aware and who want to take action, it will change policies and industries more easily. »
“Reducing is possible”
“The end of the workshop is very significant for me, because it gives the impression that we can make a big difference by educating,” shares Geneviève Fournier-Goulet, who is considering inviting the workshop to her CEGEP.
“When you see the impact of public services, it almost makes you want to do politics,” says Laure Colin, who deplores the fact that the authorities tend to sweep the need to act in the court of citizens.
Are some groups successful in achieving the goal? “In the two or three workshops that I did here, no, because common services play such an important role,” replies Théo Chevalier. In France, there are some who manage to do so. »
Trained in engineering, he was one of the first volunteer facilitators to present the 2tonnes workshop in Quebec, every other Monday evening at the Tiers Lieu. Already a facilitator for La fresco du climat, another workshop from France which helps to understand the phenomena of climate change, he wanted to offer a complementary, more positive approach.
The message we want to convey is that reducing is possible. Everyone can go their own way. Some will get there sooner, but the goal is the same and it’s entirely possible.
Théo Chevalier, one of the facilitators of the 2tonnes workshop in Quebec
“When you are aligned with environmental values, you are often seen as the extravagant person who just wants to punish others, observes Alexandre St-Pierre, a participant. In activities like these, that’s not what happens and that’s what’s nice. »
The 2tonne workshop is offered free of charge (voluntary contribution suggested). You must register on the Eventbrite platform. The next one is April 10.
Corrigendum
The name of the cooperative where the workshop was held is TLM-Un Tiers Lieu in Montreal, and not Un Tiers Lieu, as stated in an earlier version of the article. Also, since publication, 2tonnes has made action cards available in French.